The 2024 Casey Carter Scholar-Athletes of the Year
The Casey Carter Female Scholar-Athlete of the Year
Katelyn Morgan, Lacrosse
The Casey Carter Male Scholar-Athlete of the Year
​Demitri Turner, Soccer

The 2023 Casey Carter Scholar-Athletes of the Year

The Casey Carter Female Scholar-Athletes of the Year
 Katelyn Morgan, Lacrosse
Kylie Moulin, Tennis
The Casey Carter Male Scholar-Athlete of the Year
​Holden Koons, Tennis

The 2022 Casey Carter Scholar-Athletes of the Year

The Casey Carter Female Scholar-Athlete of the Year
Kylie Moulin, Tennis
The Casey Carter Male Scholar-Athlete of the Year
​Holden Koons, Tennis

​The 2021 Casey Carter Scholar-Athletes of the Year
The Casey Carter Female Scholar-Athlete of the Year
Sara Jubas, Softball
The Casey Carter Male Scholar-Athlete of the Year
​ Zach Jacobs, Basketball

The 2020 Casey Carter Scholar-Athletes of the Year

The Casey Carter Female Scholar-Athletes of the Year
Faith Anderson,
​Swim & Dive
Sara Jubas, Softball
The Casey Carter Male Scholar-Athlete of the Year
​ Kevin Kelly, Baseball

​The 2019 Casey Carter Scholar-Athletes of the Year

The Casey Carter Female Scholar-Athlete of the Year
 Erin Saunders, Cross
​Country/Track & Field
The Casey Carter Male Scholar-Athlete of the Year
 Thomas Shores, Soccer

​The 2018 Casey Carter Scholar-Athletes of the Year
The Casey Carter Female Scholar-Athlete of the Year
​Elena Romesburg, Lacrosse
The Casey Carter Male Scholar-Athlete of the Year
​
​ Bryan Schor, Football